It may or may not. A ruling in one Federal District does not necessarily mean it will be the same in another. Best thing that can happen is two different rulings. That would insure a trip to SCOTUS to settle it. There may be differences in the California law that we are not familiar with also. NY does NOT spell out 'proper cause' and is totally discretionary as to what proper cause is. I don;t know if Calif does the same or if they spell it out.Zyka said:This case may effect the Westchester suit.I believe Good Cause was the basis of the suit.The Sheriff does issue concealed carry to civilians who have proper cause.The judge determined that you must meet requirements similar to NY law.
It may or may not. A ruling in one Federal District does not necessarily mean it will be the same in another. Best thing that can happen is two different rulings. That would insure a trip to SCOTUS to settle it. There may be differences in the California law that we are not familiar with also. NY does NOT spell out 'proper cause' and is totally discretionary as to what proper cause is. I don;t know if Calif does the same or if they spell it out.Zyka said:This case may effect the Westchester suit.I believe Good Cause was the basis of the suit.The Sheriff does issue concealed carry to civilians who have proper cause.The judge determined that you must meet requirements similar to NY law.
I agree. There is very little difference between CA and NY. Gotta move away from coasts.HKFANBOY said:I hate all liberal sinkholes.
I agree. There is very little difference between CA and NY. Gotta move away from coasts.HKFANBOY said:I hate all liberal sinkholes.
The majority of the population in both states are not going to side with the pro-gun movement.Most have negative opinions of gun owners.CommackBoy said:I agree. There is very little difference between CA and NY. Gotta move away from coasts.
The majority of the population in both states are not going to side with the pro-gun movement.Most have negative opinions of gun owners.CommackBoy said:I agree. There is very little difference between CA and NY. Gotta move away from coasts.
There is one difference: the odds of California falling into the ocean are better!CommackBoy said:I agree. There is very little difference between CA and NY. Gotta move away from coasts.
There is one difference: the odds of California falling into the ocean are better!CommackBoy said:I agree. There is very little difference between CA and NY. Gotta move away from coasts.
you get me everytime with this line!!HKFANBOY said:I hate all liberal sinkholes.
you get me everytime with this line!!HKFANBOY said:I hate all liberal sinkholes.
You can't open carry in NY can you? If not, Westchester has a better argument.England countered that California law currently lets gun owners carry an unloaded weapon so it can be quickly loaded and used in self-defense if needed.
As a result, "Yolo County's policy does not substantially burden plaintiffs' right to bear and keep arms," England wrote in his 16-page decision.
You can't open carry in NY can you? If not, Westchester has a better argument.England countered that California law currently lets gun owners carry an unloaded weapon so it can be quickly loaded and used in self-defense if needed.
As a result, "Yolo County's policy does not substantially burden plaintiffs' right to bear and keep arms," England wrote in his 16-page decision.
